Blind Dog Pizza

The grain

            Without question, the most important ingredient in the pizza is the flour.  And the most important fact to remember is that all flours were NOT made equal.  There are a large number of options and choices to be made, only complicated by the availability of product online.  Different flours are going to be better suited for different purposes.  Let’s start with the basic and easiest to find. 

            The majority of flours on your store’s shelves fall under the category of All Purpose Flours.  Besides being easy to acquire, the versatility makes all purpose flour very useful.  Besides pizza, it can also be used to make bread, pancakes, pie and other pastry items and so forth.  Also, all purpose flour is the easiest to work with.  If you are interested in making deep dish or stuffed pizza, I would recommend an all purpose flour because you will get a crust with a more flavorful crumb.  This is the inside of the bread, in other words, the internal cell structure. 

            When purchasing all purpose flour, I think that it is important to look for those that are unbleached and unbromated.  If you can manage organic as well, that would also be good.   King Arthur brand flours all meet a very high standard of quality.  I use it almost exclusively. 

            The next type of flour is a bit harder to find.  “Bread flour” is distinguished for having higher gluten content than all purpose flour.  Gluten is a rubbery substance that forms in the dough when proteins in the flour combine with the water.  These strands combine to create a complex internal network.  A strong network of gluten traps gasses that form during fermentation, causing the dough to rise. 

            Bread flour is best suited for making thin crust pizzas that you may want to be crisper.  It is ideal for making a New York style thin pie.  One down side is that because of the more extensive gluten network, the dough can be harder to shape and work with than all purpose flour.

            Even more ideal for your thin crust pizzas would be high gluten flours.  When you compare protein contents, all purpose flours are generally between 10% and 12%.  Bread flour is usually between 12.5% and 13.5%.  High gluten flours come in at around 14% or 15% protein level.  Dough made using high gluten flour is very tough and hard to work so having a mixer to do the work for you would be ideal.  Also, you will likely only be able to find these flours online; so while the prices may be relatively low, the cost of shipping will make them  considerably more expensive.  King Arthur Sit Lancelot flour is available via mail order through their website.  You can also find it at www.floursack.com.  Another option, if available to you, is to find a mill or distributor near you that is willing to do cash and carry.  Of course, if you pursue this option you will likely have to buy a fifty pound bag.

            One simpler solution if you would like to use high gluten flour would be to add vital wheat gluten to your flour.  Generally, the formula is one tablespoon per cup of flour.  If you would like to get more scientific about it, there is a conversion tool online at http://www.unclesalmon.com/tools/food.php.  The tool allows you to find a more exact amount of gluten to add depending on what level of protein content you are aiming for.

            Ultimately, the best answer to this question is experimentation.  Keep a journal and make notations of your observations of different flours and what you liked about the pizza.  Store your flour in a cool, dry place.  If you are buying large quantities of flour, you may want to consider freezing it.  Storing it in the freezer can help eliminate or prevent mites or bugs that may be in the flour. 

            You may also want to invest in a sifter.  Some companies are better than others at making sure the flour is already sifted but it never hurts to do it yourself.   They are inexpensive and worth the value of having a consistently textured flour.